This box set consists of 2 adventures, ‘The Foe from the Future,’ and ‘The Valley of Death.’ Both follow the format of the show as it was in this Baker era, usually 4 or 6 episodes of 25 minutes each, complete with cliffhangers and the BBC Radiophonic Workshop’s theme music. For more on Big Finish, see here.
‘The Foe from the Future was originally intended as the conclusion to Season 14 of the classic show, with Tom Baker’s 4th Doctor and Louise Jameson’s feisty alien savage. However, the writer, Robert Banks, was reassigned to work on a troubled soap for Thames television. And the story was not able to survive without him, so Robert Holmes gave us the fan favourite “Talons of Weng-Chiang” instead.
The element in ‘Foe’ that echos in its replacement concerns its chief villain. ‘Talons’ Magnus Kreel is a genocidal disfigured maniac from the future, also a brilliant scientist. As is ‘Foe’s’ Jainik. Thereafter though, we have two very different stories.
Ghosts are haunting a peaceful Devon village, and a mysterious new owner of the local Mansion is not blending in. His name is Jainik, a spurned and disfigured lover, a brilliant scientist warped by his disfigurement and his terrible plan to evacuate a doomed future into the present. Aliens called Plantaphagens, huge insectile monsters, have invaded the future and there is only so long humanity can keep them at bay. They are creatures who live in the time vortex and they may have just have been unleashed on the future earth by Jainik and his colleagues ill advised time travel experiments.
Jainik’s mutation (he fused his DNA with a Plantaphagen in the time vortex) has also left him with a hunger for raw meat. So that’s a few minor characters done for then. It’s up to the Doctor and Leela, played by the wonderful Tom Baker and Louise Jameson reprising their original roles, to save humanity by battling these foes in the present and future, helped by Louise Brealey’s Charlotte, a villager who is swept up in the adventure.
When the story leaps from 70’s Britain to the year 4000, however, the story moves from mist shrouded, country lane gothic horror to sub-Douglas Adams 80’s era Who wackiness, as we see a future with mock ups of British life from the 70’s, rehearsal areas for an invasion from the future. There is a very ill advised scene of rescue from an alien infested desert by Ford Contina, that may work in ‘Hitchhikers Guide,’ but it just creates a massive jarring change of tone here. Leela also lasso’s a flying alien with the Doctor’s scarf and then pilots it armed with a laser pistol. It’s just daft, and doesn’t hold up. It’s a huge shame, as there is some good stuff: the cast are great, Paul Freeman as Jainik chews the scenery, portraying evil glee, paranoid rage, thwarted genius and pathos. Tom Baker is as fantastic as ever, with disarming humour and wit. Close your eyes and you can see him in his teatime tv glory. Leela nails what made her companion work so well; holding back her homicidal aggression as “The Doctor tells me that in ths time it would not be considered polite.” The cast clearly have a great time, and that is contagious, it is great fun. The story re-cycles earlier and later concepts from Who and sci-fi; (Time traveling parasites in the Vortex, witness “The Time Monster” in Pertwee Who, the Jainik mutation joins a line of disfigured maniacs in Who, but also references “The Fly” in the fusion of man and insect. The Plantaphagen’s are also distinctly “Wirrin” like. But they are used in this story with an entertaining verve
As a coherent piece of storytelling though, it doesn’t hold up, let down by an uneven tone and scenes that are just too wacky and nonsensical for any medium. It feels more like a Comic Relief tribute than a substantial adventure.
‘The Valley of Death’ is based on a story idea by Phillip Hinchcliffe, producer from my favourite era of Baker’s Doctor, and one of my favourite eras from the show as a whole. His stories were rich in concepts and ideas and had a thrilling vein of gothic horror, with very physical body horror transformation scenes.
This story is less about the horror and more about the high concepts and ideas. Here an investigation by a Grandson of a missing explorer attracts the attention of Unit and by default, the Doctor and Leela. Soon they have crash-landed in the Amazon Jungle, apparent victim of a second Bermuda Triangle as they appear to be in a middle of a plane’s graveyard, with planes from differnt decades of modern history. The missing explorer was looking for a lost city of gold, and it turns out that this city exists, but it’s a construction made by giant circuitry and ruled over by a Wizard of Oz like projection of a ship-wrecked Alien, Emissary Godrin. Godrin has surrounded the city by a time bubble that interferes with navigation systems (unintentionally) causing planes to crash. The time bubble puts him in a small sphere of influence where time moves slower than the outside world. This is because he wants time for a sufficiently advanced being to find him and help him fly his ship. He’s also created giant frogs and spiders to terrify the natives and also scare away unwanted attention. His race are called the Lurons, and they are yellow skinned, have glowing eyes, pointed ears and Piranha teeth.
You can see how many ideas are fizzing around already, and the story has hardly got going. Godrin captures the Doctor and his party, (the grandson Edward Perkins, a mannered, polite and very decent Englishman, and Valerie Perkins, a brash US reporter who has a knack for moving at the wrong time and activating traps) and they journey to 70’s London, where Godrin hijacks the BBC transmitters to call a Luron Mothership to Earth. Professing peace, they want to colonise the arid places of the Earth as their planet is dying. But can they be trusted? What do you think?
Later they create doubles of military and political figures, the Doctor and Leela, to trick Earth Authorities into giving the Lurons an easy ride. Meanwhile their ship turns out to be powered by their captive sun, held in a force-field, which has also eroded and sapped their sanity.
So you can see, high concept piles on high concept, ideas trip over each other, and somehow it works, rattling along to deliver a fun 4 part adventure that feels like Saturday teatime adventure with a throwback to flash Gordon/Dick Barton adventure serials in its innocence and unabashed love of storytelling. Many concepts will be familiar to Who fans; giant creatures, megalomaniac aliens, body doubles, which helps this feel part of the Whoniverse. It’s less baggy than ‘Foe’s’ 6 parter and more consistent in tone (it’s consistently zany). Tom Baker is on top form, sarcastically taunting villains, displaying inventive wit and anger when he has to, in well judged combination. Nigel Carrington cackles with manic glee in his portrayal of the viciously ruthless Godrin, a classic alien Who baddie, I could picture him clearly on my childhood’s tv screen from the 70’s. Louise Jamison is wonderful with Leela, showing the character with its winning combination of toughness and naivety, and giving her loads to do. Anthony Howell’s Edward Perkins is a decent, bumbling Englishman much in the Harry Sullivan mode. Jane Slavin’s brash but accident prone Valerie Carlton is a good foil to him. They make good temporary companions.
Sound production is excellent, recreating the sound and feel of this show from the 1970’s.
This is a pricey box set and I would say that it’s not the best jumping on point for Big Finish (unless you are a pretty established classic Who fan already) but on the whole it’s a fun listen, and a fascinating attempt to bring these lost stories to life. And how wonderful to hear Tom Baker and Louise Jameson in action again.